Votes for deletion/KROQ Top 106.7 Countdowns
Free ringtones KROQ Top 106.7 Countdowns, along with Majo Mills KROQ Top 106.7 Countdown of 1980, Mosquito ringtone KROQ Top 106.7 Countdown of 1981, and Sabrina Martins KROQ Top 106.7 Countdown of 1982, was proposed for deletion. This page is an archive of the discussion about the proposed deletionNextel ringtones Template:Vfd top/. '''This page is no longer live.''' Further comments should be made on the article's talk page rather than here so that this page is preserved as an historic record. The result of the debate was to keep all.
Just a bunch of end-of-year countdown playlists for a Los Angeles radio station. Not encyclopedic. Abbey Diaz Gwalla/ — Free ringtones User:Gwalla/Gwalla / Majo Mills User talk:Gwalla/Talk 03:50, 13 Nov 2004
*Agree. '''Delete'''. Mosquito ringtone Ian Pugh/Ian Pugh 04:12, 13 Nov 2004
*Extremely unencyclopedic. Articles getting '''deleted''' in 4..3..2... Sabrina Martins Wyllium/Wyllium 04:58, 2004 Nov 13
*'''Keep.''' This particular one may be debatable, but there's some similar lists that are indeed encyclopedic, and I'm very unwilling to set a precedent. Cingular Ringtones Ambi/Ambi 05:34, 13 Nov 2004
*'''Keep'''. This radio station pretends to be the Billboard countdown every year as their gimmick. It should at least be famous for their extremely funny parody of the Billboard. maladjusted genius Rather/Rather 05:48, 13 Nov 2004
*Delete. Note that the user above has only one edit (and it's vandalism). communist revolutionaries Everyking/Everyking 06:06, 13 Nov 2004
*'''Surprisingly strong keep,''' and one I wouldn't give if with widely KROQ wasn't one of the most notable radio stations in North America; for newly-released rock music in English, it is certainly ''the'' most notable in the world. I'm on the other side of the continent and I've never heard it for a moment, but its reputation precedes it. Merge & redirect would hideously clutter the station's main article. the gigabyte Samaritan/Samaritan 06:09, 13 Nov 2004
** agreed, '''keep''' on the basis that KROQ is particularly notable be saddled Clarahamster/clara 06:51, Nov 13, 2004
**I've no doubt of KROQ's notability (stalled tobacco Rodney Bingenheimer alone guarantees that). However, I don't believe the individual countdowns are necessary to illustrate it. upturned boats Ian Pugh/Ian Pugh 07:12, 13 Nov 2004
***Not to illustrate. But they'd be useful and germane to knowledge of chapter vygotsky 1980 in music, me you 1981 in music, etc. independently. enriches future Samaritan/Samaritan 07:56, 13 Nov 2004
****OK, you've convinced me. However, my suggestion would be to '''merge''' with those articles. fosse used Ian Pugh/Ian Pugh 09:41, 14 Nov 2004
*****I think any countdown list greater than 10-20 entries directly in the same article would be too cluttered. quickly criticized Samaritan/Samaritan 23:02, 14 Nov 2004
*Keep harm much Siroxo/ —four houseguests User:Siroxo/siroground while User talk:Siroxo/''χ''defensive replacement Contributions/Siroxo/o 09:11, Nov 13, 2004
*'''Keep'''. lamentations about KROQ is the 600-pound gorilla of rock trendsetting and their countdowns are snapshots of the rock zeitgeist for that year. young formerly Mendel/ — mate just User:mendel/mendel ana tel User_talk:Mendel/☎ 14:02, Nov 13, 2004
*'''Keep'''. Notable, as illustrated above. ElBenevolente/ElBenevolente 18:20, 13 Nov 2004
*'''Keep'''. This is both historical and noteworthy and would be a travesty to lose. GRider/GRider 19:23, 13 Nov 2004
*Keep - David Gerard/David Gerard 21:03, 13 Nov 2004
*Keep - historically significant radio station. Useful information. Moncrief/Moncrief 23:52, Nov 13, 2004
*'''K''' If it's anything like John Peel's end-of-year countdowns on Radio 1, then really they should stay. Chriscf/Chris 05:15, 14 Nov 2004
*'''Keep''' it. Radman1/en:RaD Man/'''RaD Man''' (User_talk:Radman1/''talk'') 06:42, 14 Nov 2004
*'''Weak keep''' for KROQ Top 106.7 Countdowns, but '''Strong delete''' for each of the yearly countdowns which can already be found following the links on the main coundown page and don't need to be repeated in the Wikipedia. (from an long-time KROQ listener) GK/gK User talk:GK/¿? 12:08, 16 Nov 2004
*'''Keep'''Pedant/Pedant 04:08, 2004 Nov 18
This page is now preserved as an archive of the debate and, like other '/delete' pages is no longer 'live'. Subsequent comments on the issue, the deletion or on the decision-making process should be placed on the relevant 'live' pages. '''Please do not edit this page'''Template:Vfd bottom/.
Just a bunch of end-of-year countdown playlists for a Los Angeles radio station. Not encyclopedic. Abbey Diaz Gwalla/ — Free ringtones User:Gwalla/Gwalla / Majo Mills User talk:Gwalla/Talk 03:50, 13 Nov 2004
*Agree. '''Delete'''. Mosquito ringtone Ian Pugh/Ian Pugh 04:12, 13 Nov 2004
*Extremely unencyclopedic. Articles getting '''deleted''' in 4..3..2... Sabrina Martins Wyllium/Wyllium 04:58, 2004 Nov 13
*'''Keep.''' This particular one may be debatable, but there's some similar lists that are indeed encyclopedic, and I'm very unwilling to set a precedent. Cingular Ringtones Ambi/Ambi 05:34, 13 Nov 2004
*'''Keep'''. This radio station pretends to be the Billboard countdown every year as their gimmick. It should at least be famous for their extremely funny parody of the Billboard. maladjusted genius Rather/Rather 05:48, 13 Nov 2004
*Delete. Note that the user above has only one edit (and it's vandalism). communist revolutionaries Everyking/Everyking 06:06, 13 Nov 2004
*'''Surprisingly strong keep,''' and one I wouldn't give if with widely KROQ wasn't one of the most notable radio stations in North America; for newly-released rock music in English, it is certainly ''the'' most notable in the world. I'm on the other side of the continent and I've never heard it for a moment, but its reputation precedes it. Merge & redirect would hideously clutter the station's main article. the gigabyte Samaritan/Samaritan 06:09, 13 Nov 2004
** agreed, '''keep''' on the basis that KROQ is particularly notable be saddled Clarahamster/clara 06:51, Nov 13, 2004
**I've no doubt of KROQ's notability (stalled tobacco Rodney Bingenheimer alone guarantees that). However, I don't believe the individual countdowns are necessary to illustrate it. upturned boats Ian Pugh/Ian Pugh 07:12, 13 Nov 2004
***Not to illustrate. But they'd be useful and germane to knowledge of chapter vygotsky 1980 in music, me you 1981 in music, etc. independently. enriches future Samaritan/Samaritan 07:56, 13 Nov 2004
****OK, you've convinced me. However, my suggestion would be to '''merge''' with those articles. fosse used Ian Pugh/Ian Pugh 09:41, 14 Nov 2004
*****I think any countdown list greater than 10-20 entries directly in the same article would be too cluttered. quickly criticized Samaritan/Samaritan 23:02, 14 Nov 2004
*Keep harm much Siroxo/ —four houseguests User:Siroxo/siroground while User talk:Siroxo/''χ''defensive replacement Contributions/Siroxo/o 09:11, Nov 13, 2004
*'''Keep'''. lamentations about KROQ is the 600-pound gorilla of rock trendsetting and their countdowns are snapshots of the rock zeitgeist for that year. young formerly Mendel/ — mate just User:mendel/mendel ana tel User_talk:Mendel/☎ 14:02, Nov 13, 2004
*'''Keep'''. Notable, as illustrated above. ElBenevolente/ElBenevolente 18:20, 13 Nov 2004
*'''Keep'''. This is both historical and noteworthy and would be a travesty to lose. GRider/GRider 19:23, 13 Nov 2004
*Keep - David Gerard/David Gerard 21:03, 13 Nov 2004
*Keep - historically significant radio station. Useful information. Moncrief/Moncrief 23:52, Nov 13, 2004
*'''K''' If it's anything like John Peel's end-of-year countdowns on Radio 1, then really they should stay. Chriscf/Chris 05:15, 14 Nov 2004
*'''Keep''' it. Radman1/en:RaD Man/'''RaD Man''' (User_talk:Radman1/''talk'') 06:42, 14 Nov 2004
*'''Weak keep''' for KROQ Top 106.7 Countdowns, but '''Strong delete''' for each of the yearly countdowns which can already be found following the links on the main coundown page and don't need to be repeated in the Wikipedia. (from an long-time KROQ listener) GK/gK User talk:GK/¿? 12:08, 16 Nov 2004
*'''Keep'''Pedant/Pedant 04:08, 2004 Nov 18
This page is now preserved as an archive of the debate and, like other '/delete' pages is no longer 'live'. Subsequent comments on the issue, the deletion or on the decision-making process should be placed on the relevant 'live' pages. '''Please do not edit this page'''Template:Vfd bottom/.
posted at 5:31 PM
0 Comments:
Post a Comment
<< Home